[Report Abuse]
[Login to Blog] timeontarget's Blog
From American Thinker
Last comment by JimmyMack 5 months, 1 week ago.

Take Me To Post Comment Form

April 8, 2014
The Poverty Hoax
By John Dietrich


A major concern of progressives is their supposed interest in the fate of the poor. They purport to be the champions of the poor. But the truth is that they need the poor more than the poor need them, in a symbiotic relationship. As much as 75% of the money allocated to the poor is consumed by the vast bureaucracies that administer this aid.

These agencies are actually job programs for college graduates who would often find it difficult to find employment in the private sector.

The late William Raspberry wrote a column dealing with Gina, a 14 year old living in a group home, who had a caseworker, a psychotherapist and a court appointed lawyer. These caregivers have to be supported by a number of clerical workers and supervisors who compose the vast helping bureaucracy.

If the "poor" were suddenly to disappear they would have to redefine their definition of poverty in order to maintain their sinecures. And that is exactly what they have done.

Advocates for the poor do not ordinarily live by what they preach. The President has informed us that, “We can't drive our SUVs and eat as much as we want and keep our homes on 72 degrees at all times.”

Yet during a recent trip to China the first family and their staff of about 70 stayed in the presidential suite at the Westin Chaoyang Hotel, which USA Today reports costs about $8,400 a night.

Clearly the elite live by a different standard and have for a long time. Communist defector Victor Kravchenko recalled that during the famine in the Soviet Union, “I found myself among men who could eat ample and dainty food in full view of starving people not only with a clear conscience but with a feeling of righteousness, as if they were performing a duty to history.”

What is poverty? The late political scientist Edward Banfield provided four degrees of poverty:

destitution, which is lack of income sufficient to assure physical survival and to prevent suffering from hunger, exposure, or remediable or preventable illness; want, which is lack of enough income to support essential welfare;

hardship, which is lack of enough to prevent acute persistent discomfort or inconvenience.

To this he added a fourth: relative deprivation which is a lack of enough income, status, or whatever else may be valued to prevent one from feeling poor in comparison to others.

This last category is elastic enough to include millionaires who covet the possessions and power of billionaires.

One important category of poverty Banfield does not mention is psychological or spiritual poverty.

This is the most significant form of poverty in an affluent society when physical needs are easily met.


Where do America's "poor" stand in this scale of poverty? In a nation of over 300 million people there are undoubtedly cases of destitution, want and hardship.

However, these cases appear to be the exception. As former Secretary of Agriculture Dan Glickman stated,

"More people die in the United States of too much food than of too little."

According to William Bennett, "Poor people in America have a higher standard of living than middle-class Americans of previous generations."

According to the Heritage Foundation, 80% of poor households have air conditioning.

Nearly three-fourths have a car or truck, and 31% have two or more.

Two-thirds of poor households have cable or satellite TV with 18% having a big screen television.

And .6% of poor households own a Jacuzzi.

The Los Angeles Times reported the California's "poor" spent $69 million using their welfare payments on at least 14 cruise ships sailing from Miami and other ports, at Disney World, in Hawaii and Guam and at hotels in Las Vegas.

Many of the "poor" enjoy luxuries that the Pharaohs of ancient Egypt would envy.

Heather MacDonald claimed in 2000 that New York City spent $790 million on the homeless, or $39,500 per person.

According to Robert Rector of the Heritage Foundation the U.S. has spent over $20.7 trillion on means-tested welfare since the beginning of the War on Poverty.

The failure to eliminate "poverty" is a result of the faulty assumptions made about the poor.

Many believe that the poor are "just like us" except for the fact that they do not have money.

Even such an astute observer as George Orwell believed that providing material support for the poor would improve their behavior.

"Give people a decent house and they will soon learn to keep it decent. Moreover, with a smart-looking house to live up to, they improve in self-respect and cleanliness, and their children start life with better chances."

It has become obvious that this is not the case.

The "poor" have a different set of values condemning them to poverty regardless of how much money is lavished on them. A professional athlete may make $300 million during his career and yet retire in poverty.

As Banfield has stated, "the capacity of the radically improvident to waste money is almost unlimited."

This brings us to the last form of poverty:

psychological or spiritual poverty.

Mother Teresa commented at Harvard,

“America is not a rich country.

America is a desperately spiritually poor country.”

This “spiritual” poverty hits the poor particularly hard.

Vladimir Bukovsky noted this upon his arrival in the United States.

Having been born and raised in “genuine” poverty he noted that he, “detected everywhere the spirit of ostentatious defiance.

The worse it looks, the better, because society is to blame.”

American poor made a concerted effort to exhibit their poverty.

Advocate for the poor complain that there are "food deserts" in the inner cities. It might also be noted that these areas suffer from being “hardware store deserts.”

Yet there is no shortage of nail salons and liquor stores in these neighborhoods.

The market determines what people are interested in buying.

Tennis shoes, costing several hundred dollars, a pair are not marketed to middle class youth. The target market is inner city youth.

Myron Magnet tells the story of author Amy Tan’s sister and brother-in-law who arrived from China in 1983. After only four years in America, they owned a car, three televisions and a house. They also had two children in college. They accomplished this all with dead-end jobs: he washed dishes and she helped manage a takeout restaurant.

Reporter Jacob A. Riis described the attitude of Jewish immigrants early in the 20th century:

“The poorest Hebrew knows – the poorer he is, the better he knows it – that knowledge is power, and power as the means of getting on in the world that has spurned him so long, is what his soul yearns for.

He lets no opportunity slip to obtain it. Day- and night-schools are crowded with his children, who learn rapidly and with ease.

Every synagogue, every second rear tenement or dark back-yard, has its school and its school master, with his scourge to intercept those who might otherwise escape.”

According to Magnet, the successes of present day Asian immigrants “contains an implicit reproach” to the indigenous poor.

Many arrive with little capital and a poor command of the language, but through hard work become successful.

Innumerable studies have been conducted on poverty's causes and cures.

Perhaps the assertion of President Franklin Roosevelt says it best:

“Continued dependence upon relief induces a spiritual and moral disintegration fundamentally destructive to the national fiber.

To dole out relief in this way is to administer a narcotic, a subtle destroyer of the human spirit.”

Certainly progressive academics are aware of the consequences of their policies.

Perhaps that is their ultimate goal.

John Dietrich is a freelance writer and the author of The Morgenthau Plan: Soviet Influence on American Postwar Policy, Algora Publishing, 2013. http://johndietrichbooks.blogspot.com/


Latest Activity: Apr 09, 2014 at 6:51 AM


Bookmark and Share
Forward This Blog
Print Blog
More Blogs by timeontarget
Send timeontarget a Message
Report Abuse


Blog has been viewed (391) times.

JimmyMack commented on Wednesday, Apr 09, 2014 at 08:18 AM

Tot, have you ever considered your repetitious daily cut and pastes are very similar to Murrellet's constant and also repetitious posts of:

BOOM,BOOM,BOOM
BOOM, BOOM
BOOM, BOOM, BOOM...etc?

Both are symptomatic of various degrees of OCD.

timeontarget commented on Wednesday, Apr 09, 2014 at 12:10 PM

JM, because of you I am not comfortable writing my own thoughts on this medium.

You once vowed to make timeontarget your special project and eventually I just became tired of the constant vile which you posted about the person known as timeontarget.

I once commented that you were singlehandedly causing me and others to refrain from participating.

You obviously don't consider the content of the blogs which I post.

You are nothing but a flaming liberal who attacks any messenger whose opinion differs from yours.

When Liberals have nothing meaningful to say they simply attack the messenger.

Why don't you take the time to read the content of tot's recent blogs?

JimmyMack commented on Wednesday, Apr 09, 2014 at 13:07 PM

Good afternoon to you too, Tot. Anyone and I mean anyone who speaks or writes for PUBLIC consumption is held to the same standards. That is why we have laws regarding SLANDER: the spoken word, and LIBEL: the written word. If one crosses those lines then that person answers to the MAN.

You Tot, label entire GROUPS of people in a negative manner far more serious than the gnat bites that you get from me.

I have told you before: you are not built for this. You reached your Liberal bashing line by associating me and other Liberals as being accessories to the MURDER of them 20 children and 6 adults at Sandy Hook. You can dish it out Tot, but you just can't take it. And yes, when you throw out your reckless mean spirited words I am forever going to respond. The fact that you hide in the shadows of anonymity by not posting a profile, and now only cut and paste words of others speaks volumes regarding your character. You Tot, can hide under your rock but you can rest assured that I, JIMMY DARSEY, am going to pound on the top of that rock til you slither out from under it.

As Muhammed Ali said, "you can run, but you can't hide."

I WILL defend myself Tot and I am not going to make it easy to allow a cowardly name caller like yourself slip away and hide without getting bit. Often.

timeontarget commented on Wednesday, Apr 09, 2014 at 15:41 PM

As much as 75% of the money allocated to the poor is consumed by the vast bureaucracies that administer this aid.

These agencies are actually job programs for college graduates who would often find it difficult to find employment in the private sector.

JimmyMack commented on Friday, Apr 11, 2014 at 16:38 PM

Tot. Have you been bitten by a bed bug or anything like that recently? Maybe a yellow fly?

JimmyMack commented on Friday, Apr 11, 2014 at 17:26 PM

Tot: Are you referring only to VA facilities or things like Christian Children's Fund, SPCA, Feed the Children, The Clean Water Project...?

If you are....then PROVE IT. You uninformed Goat. And also take an intellectual stab at where the VA assistance $$ for our military is going with PROOF!

You know those men and women standing in harms way for you to voice your hate. Free Speech.

timeontarget commented on Saturday, Apr 12, 2014 at 15:39 PM

I am finished with talking with you JM

Sgt Waters said "Never argue with a fool because the by-standers cannot tell who is who".

JimmyMack commented on Saturday, Apr 12, 2014 at 18:43 PM

You were finished before you started.

You ain't built for this medium, TOT.

Seems Sgt. Waters was an intellectual giant. I guess the 'bystanders' will just have to flip a coin.

Dem's your kind of odds Tot.


Log In to post comments.

Previous blog entries by timeontarget
 
Where is sebekm????????????
September 14, 2014
I don't recall seeing any blogs or comments from sebekm for several weeks now. I hope he is perhaps out of town temporarily. I hope we have not lost him. He is one of the most level headed contributors to this site. We especially could benefit from his input about ...
Read More »
 
The Forever War by Pat Buchanan
September 12, 2014
The latest from Pat Buchanan on the mess the world faces in the tribal nations of the middle east and some informative commentary regarding what might happen as we slowly stumble forward. "The Forever War Friday - September 12, 2014 at 12:05 am By Patrick J. Buchanan The strategy that ...
Read More »
 
Jimmy Carter Raises Money For Terrorists
September 02, 2014
September 2, 2014 by Chip Wood Jimmy Carter Raises Money For Terrorists SPECIAL Former President Jimmy Carter has done and said a lot of stupid things over the past 40 years. But the muddle-headed octogenarian may have reached a new low. He agreed to be the featured speaker at an ...
Read More »
 
Has Hillary Ever Been Right?
August 30, 2014
Has Hillary Ever Been Right? Friday - August 29, 2014 at 12:12 am By Patrick J. Buchanan Sen. Rand Paul raises an interesting question: When has Hillary Clinton ever been right on foreign policy? The valkyrie of the Democratic Party says she urged President Obama to do more to aid ...
Read More »
 
Rand Paul / Hillary Clinton
August 30, 2014
This piece was published in Bob Livingston's PERSONAL LIBERTY DIGEST. I personally hope that Senator Paul is correct. ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// August 28, 2014 by Sam Rolley Rand Paul: Hillary Clinton Is A Warmonger Who Would Get Clobbered In 2016 UPI Sen. Rand Paul (R-Ky.) this week blasted former Secretary of State— ...
Read More »
 
[View More Blogs...]





 
Powered by
Morris Technology